Main Answer
Scripture does not give one simple explanation for every case of righteous suffering. Job rejects the idea that suffering always proves personal guilt, and Jesus refuses a similar assumption when His disciples ask about the man born blind.
Job’s friends repeatedly try to fit his pain into a moral formula. The book exposes the limits of that approach. In John 9, Jesus also rejects the disciples’ attempt to identify a specific sin as the cause of the man’s condition.
The Bible gives several categories for suffering, including living in a fallen world, persecution, consequences of choices and mysteries that are not fully explained to the sufferer.
The absence of a complete explanation does not mean God is indifferent. Scripture gives the sufferer permission to ask questions while calling the community to compassion rather than accusation.
For a related free study, read How Can Job and Proverbs Both Be True About Righteous Suffering?.
For a fuller guided study, see Uncovering Faith: A Christian Devotional on Suffering (available to our members also).
The Extra Study below stays with Job 1-2 and John 9:1-3, checks the most likely misuse of the passage and develops a practical response for ordinary Christian life.
(more…)