Main Answer
The person in 2 Corinthians 2 cannot be identified with certainty. He had caused serious grief and had received punishment from the majority of the church. Paul now says that the discipline was sufficient and tells the Corinthians to forgive, comfort and reaffirm their love so that the person is not overwhelmed by excessive sorrow.
Some readers identify him with the sexually immoral man of 1 Corinthians 5. Others think he was a different person who had publicly insulted or challenged Paul during the painful visit. The wording of 2 Corinthians appears personal, yet Paul does not provide enough information to settle the question.
The uncertainty protects readers from building the main lesson upon speculation. Paul’s focus is not the man’s name or the details of his offence. He is concerned with what the church should do after discipline has achieved its purpose and the offender has responded.
Why Paul Calls for Forgiveness
The punishment imposed by the majority had caused real sorrow. Continuing to hold the man beneath condemnation could now destroy rather than restore him. Paul therefore asks the church to comfort him and formally confirm its love.
Forgiveness does not mean that the original wrong was unimportant. The church had taken action, and Paul had written with pain. Restoration becomes appropriate because the response to sin has reached its intended goal. Christian discipline should seek repentance, safety and renewed faithfulness rather than permanent humiliation.
Key point
The passage shows that a church can fail in two directions: refusing to confront serious wrongdoing, or refusing to restore a repentant person after correction has done its work.
“So that contrariwise ye ought rather to forgive him, and comfort him, lest perhaps such a one should be swallowed up with overmuch sorrow.”
2 Corinthians 2:7, KJV
The painful history behind this instruction is traced in the complete 2 Corinthians study guide.
The Extra Study below compares the main views about the offender, explains the purpose of church discipline and considers how forgiveness can be offered without ignoring safety, accountability or continuing harm.
(more…)